The Scrappy Wiki
Advertisement
Click To Defeat Mal!
Mal finds the infobox on this page admirable, as its pretty dead, as evidenced by how many, if not all sections, in it are as empty as his heart and the land he rules. Next thing you know, he might rule over it.
Prevent this from happening by updating and expanding the infobox.



Mark: "Why are you dating him? He's bullying your brother!"

Maggie: "Who are you, my father?"

~ -Maggie proving why she has a page on this wiki.

Maggie O'Donnell is a secondary character from the 2009 movie 17 Again. She's Mike and Scarlet's 18-year-old daughter. Her conception was the reason Mike chose to abandon his dreams and marry Scarlet. She dates Stan.

She was played by the late Michelle Trachtenberg.

What Makes Her A Scrappy?[]

  • She comes up as a shallow and bratty teenager stereotype and unlike the rest of her family doesn't get much in character development or being likable in her own right.
  • While Mike is implied to be a bit of a distant father this rarely shows on screen and never seems to blame anyone in his family for his unhappiness, meanwhile Maggie refuses to make an effort when Mike genuinely tries to reach out to her and pretends to listen music to not hear him, which makes Mike look more sympathetic and Maggie as a jerkass.
  • Her sadness over breaking up with Stan for not wanting to sleep with him is meant to come up as sympathetic but the fact that she was dating someone who was constantly a jerkass and a bully to everyone and glossed over a bunch of condoms over her face in the middle of a class makes her come up as hypocrital and downright delusional over Stan's flaws.
  • She also completely ignores the suffering of her brother Alex, who Stan constantly bullies both in the school and the house, since she constantly invites him to the house, making her sadness even less sympathetic and more like karma.
  • She treats Mark with disdain since their very first interaction only for simply looking at her direction.
  • Once Stan breaks up with her, she tries to force herself onto the first nice boy that tried to consulate her (not knowing is her father) despise treating the same boy with disdain in every previous scene and once she know he's in love with someone else promised to ruin their relationship.
  • She can also come up as egocentric, considering that in the moment Mike/Mark rejects her advances, she immediately assumes he's gay.
  • Her anger over Mark/Mike kissing her mother is supposed to be justifiable but considering her previous scene and her bitter look when he seems to talk with her, she rather comes up as feeling entitled to Mark's love (again someone who she has treated with disdain in every previous scene).
  • Unlike the rest of the family, she lacks any positive interactions with the rest of her family and seems to lack any personality beyond her relationship with her father and her obsession with Stan.
Advertisement